
There’s a park in San José where neighbors have wanted to paint a mural on a park structure for more than two years. They reached out to the Arts Commission (AC) and the Office of Cultural Affairs (OCA) and the Public Arts Commission (PAC) to get the ball rolling. More than two years later, the wall is still waiting.
Then we found another way to move the project forward. Within 48 hours, we had a plan, a budget, a schedule, help covering the supplies, and neighbors ready to pick up a paintbrush.
The neighbors are scheduled to paint within the next two weeks. If all goes as planned, we’ll go from our first planning conversations to a finished mural in about three weeks. And for years to come, someone will walk through that park with their kid or grandkid, point to the wall, and say, “I helped paint that.”
That’s the part that makes me smile. It’s also the part that makes me wonder why we make this so hard.
I used to serve on the San José Arts Commission, and a two-year wait for a mural doesn’t surprise me. The wait is never ending. From what I saw, a statue could take more than eight years or more to just get moving. For this mural, the OCA would expect the neighborhood to spend about $20,000 to work with a “city-approved artist” if we went through the city’s process.
As a working artist, I want artists to be paid fairly. So I have to ask what good an approved artist list does if the projects that could pay those artists keep getting stuck. A roster looks good on a website. What you don’t see on that page is how much work comes out of it. During my time on the commission, I saw projects sit at the Office of Cultural Affairs without a clear next step or a staff person responsible for moving them forward. The request stops there, and nothing happens. Every project that sits there is a missed opportunity for an artist to get paid and for a neighborhood to get a piece of art.
There’s another part of this that hits close to home. I was going to receive a small stipend (from another city entity) for my volunteer work on this mural. I was told the Office of Cultural Affairs and the Public Arts Commission wouldn’t allow a volunteer to receive a stipend, so I’m doing it for free. I’m okay with that. I want to help my neighbors paint this wall. But I’ve heard the Office of Cultural Affairs talk about how important it is to pay artists, and here we are. The project sat for more than two years, the stipend fell through, and so far, nobody has been paid for the art. This has been happening for many years. Why?
I also believe everyone is an artist. A neighbor who’s never painted a mural should have a chance to put some color on a wall in the park they use every day. I want San José to make room for that kind of project and for paid work by professional artists. There’s plenty of room for both.
What if we had a simple, clear way to get public art approved in San José? For a neighborhood mural, you’d have a suitable wall, permission from whoever owns it, neighbors who agree on the project, and someone at the city who can tell you what comes next and when you’ll hear back. Think how much art could bloom around this city if people knew how to get started and had someone to help them through it.
I keep coming back to those first 48 hours. We had neighbors willing to give their time, people willing to help with supplies, and a wall that had been waiting for more than two years. How many other neighborhoods in San José are ready to do the same thing?
We can do better, San José. Art is life, and it deserves room to grow right where we live. I think it’s time to burn the red tape.
A’ho.
Namaste — Karen



